New 50 ml glass bottles30-day money-back guarantee

Moumoujus
Chartreuse leaf veins behind an ivory cream swipe on sunlit grey stone

Investigations

How to Check Clinical Skincare Claims

Learn what ingredient percentages and clinical studies can tell you about a skincare product, and which questions to ask before comparing formulas.

· 4 min read

A published percentage is useful information, but it is not a potency score. A clinical claim is only as informative as the study behind it. Before comparing skincare, check what was tested and what the numbers actually describe.

An earlier version of this article ranked named brands and inferred performance from estimated ingredient concentrations. We have removed that scorecard because those estimates did not support the conclusions, including our own product’s superiority claims.

1. Read the percentage carefully

Ask whether a percentage refers to a pure ingredient, an ingredient blend or something else. A 3% ceramide complex is not necessarily 3% pure ceramides. A 2% peptide blend is not necessarily 2% pure peptide. Without the blend composition, those figures cannot be converted into a pure-active concentration or compared on that basis.

More is not automatically better. A higher headline number cannot establish that a product is more effective, better tolerated or worth a higher price.

2. Use the ingredient list for what it shows

The full ingredient list helps identify ingredients and things you know you need to avoid. It is not an exact concentration assay. Under Great Britain’s cosmetic labelling rules, ingredients below 1% may appear in any order after those above 1%. Position alone does not prove an ingredient is present at an ineffective dose.

3. Check what the study tested

  • Was it the product being sold, an ingredient preparation or a different formula?
  • Was it a laboratory experiment, a human study or a customer survey?
  • What comparator, sample, duration and outcome were used?
  • Do the reported results match the claim, rather than a different benefit?

For example, a 2007 trial of a 2% ectoin formula assessed hydration and skin-ageing measures in healthy women. It was not a trial of The Mantle, and it does not establish the same effect in a serum containing 1.5% ectoin. Our ectoin guide explains that distinction in more detail.

4. Apply the same standard to The Mantle

The Mantle is a fragrance-free barrier serum with 1.5% ectoin, a 3% ceramide complex and a 2% peptide blend. The ceramide and peptide percentages refer to ingredient blends, rather than pure ceramide or pure peptide content.

These are published formulation inputs. They do not establish superiority over another brand, a guaranteed recovery time or a clinical outcome for the finished serum. Adding selected blend percentages together does not produce a comparable total-active score.

The ingredient list also includes an apple cell culture extract and black tea ferment. We do not infer an exosome identity from those names; see our guide to evaluating exosome claims.

5. Compare products on useful, supported details

Compare the texture, full formula, current price and directions, then examine the evidence for any outcome that matters to you. Customer reviews can describe experience; they cannot replace a controlled study. An undisclosed percentage is a gap in public information, not proof that a brand is dishonest or a product cannot work.

Our ceramide buying guide compares published format and formula details without turning them into an efficacy ranking.

Sources: GB cosmetic labelling guidance; Heinrich et al. (2007), ectoin trial abstract. These sources do not test or endorse The Mantle.

Read The Mantle’s formula details

The Mantle is a fragrance-free barrier serum with 1.5% ectoin, a 3% ceramide complex and a 2% peptide blend. The ceramide and peptide percentages refer to ingredient blends, rather than pure ceramide or pure peptide content.

Explore The Mantle →

Disclosure: Moumoujus makes The Mantle. This guide separates ingredient information from evidence about the finished serum. Reviewed 16 October 2026.

The Mantle in its frosted glass bottle with a gold pump

Made by Moumoujus

The Mantle Extremolyte Barrier Serum

£48.005.0 (23 reviews)

1.5% Ectoin, 3% Ceramide complex, 2% Peptide blend. Fragrance-free, for sensitive and reactive skin.

Shop The MantleFree delivery · 30-day money-back guarantee